 |
Note: I have not run this adventure. My review is based on reading through the content.
This is an exceptional adventure for what it is: a Fourthcore and classic tournament styled adventure provided by a third-party publisher (and for free!). This style of adventure places an emphasis on attempting to complete an adventure where traps, puzzles, and random elements can create failure. Fans of that genre should be pleased. In addition, the adventure has so many interesting bits that even those who do not care for the exact style should be able to mine its contents for cool ideas to use in their own style of adventures.
The writing and production quality are both superior to those typically found in third-party products. While we can pick nits, overall it is clear that effort and skill have been applied here to create a great experience for the DM reading through the content and for the players that will experience the adventure. Writing is strong, formatting is clean and legible, monsters and traps are well constructed and fun, etc. A really neat aspect is how the author places Trivia sidebars sharing how real-world history and games have influenced the writing of the adventure. It shows how the author cares for the DM and for gaming history.
There are some fun, if gamist, concepts for various encounters. For example, a deck is used during a maze to determine progress. Random treasure cards are used. Rumor cards are provided and have a label as to how reliable the information might be. The location of some adventure components can vary with play. These aspects resemble old RPGA tournament adventures. Similarly, there are cases where the adventure can feel a bit thin. For example, an NPC where there could be interesting interaction, but the adventure really focuses on a particular item being provided. It makes the NPC into a puzzle rather than a social interaction. There is a reason for it, but it fits a particular play style and could probably please more audiences. That said, it isn't a big deal and a DM can change this very easily.
I'll leave lethality and game play to another reviewer. A quick perusal shows some tough monsters - some seem overly challenging for an adventure that must be completed in 4 hours. However, it will take actual play to confirm this. And, because scoring is the drive, it may not be a bad thing if players can't easily complete the adventure.
|
|
|
Log In 
.jpg)
