|
|
|
 |
| Other comments left by this customer: |
|
|
|
|
|
Whereas their last installment was a methodological paced mystery that climaxed in a confined location, EN Publishing’s Digging For Lies, the third installment of the Zeitgeist campaign, is a dynamic difference in both scope and action.
The Zeitgeist Campaign continues to be an engaging read with every release. This is the largest adventure ever, some 90+ pages. The color choices, formatting and layout work are top notch. Whether you are reading 4th edition or Pathfinder, the mechanics are sharp and witty. The Pathfinder edition is especially impressive, as the mechanics never feel like a bastard version of something else but an organic set of rules.
Lies shoots a party across the landscape of the Zeitgeist continent of Risur, exploring secret archeological sites, brings them before a fey titan, bargaining for the fate of the world, then lulls their fears in their fears by placing them in a familiar place, only to place it under an intense siege. The mystery element of Zeitgeist is still there, as the players figure out whether they are pawns or players in a massive conspiracy.
For the Dungeon Master
Lies also includes a great set of Ship to Ship combat rule that are useful inside or outside of the game. DMs will also never feel lost in these adventures.
The Iron Word
Zeitgeist #3 Digging for Lies is another remarkable adventure. Once the adventure hits Act 2, it feels like a nonstop climax that does not let go until the very end.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I normally do not write reviews for preview products, especially when there are hundreds if thousands of versions of the subject matter scattered throughout the internet. However, I really like where Geek Corps Production is headed with their Critical Hits and Fumble Cards.
The critical/fumble chart has been done before. Go to any forum on any given day and you’ll find one. Last year, a couple years ago, Paizo produced two of these products. I used the Paizo versions in my last campaign, but the design made them cumbersome, too vague or useless.
Geek Crops does not just reinvent the world, they make a square roll. Instead of a simple chart or a line of text for each action, they added several more descriptive items to each card. They also included visual identifiers to make their cards more interesting. The description is great for keeping the immersion of your game. Underneath are the mechanical effects for each card, which does a solid job of summarizing damage dealt, the overall effect and any conditions now implemented on the player. In these samples, effects aren’t duplicated, which really produces a wild feeling of not knowing what will happen.
For the Dungeon Master
The design is what makes this product exciting to use. The cards are easy to use and add to the description of the game.
The Iron Word
The creativity of the cards breathes life into the critical and fumble charts floating around and makes this product worth paying for when it comes out. I would advise any dungeon master of any system to put this high on your watch list.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Massive Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games have had a negative effect as far as expectations from tabletop games. It is great that their popularity has driven more people to find tabletop RPGs, but when trying to explain roles, conversations sometimes end in, how do I tank or why is there more to healing that standing back and casting heals or, hey why is this creature attacking me and not the guy in the heavy armor yelling at him.
The Genius Guide to the Armiger presents a class that Is a great hybrid between the two style, introducing a “tank” class that fits into tabletop confirms. The class modifies a traditional fighter class with lower BAB and better saves and gives a bunch of options that aid in protecting others. I was very glad that the designers did not add a “taunt” or “agro” ability, instead allowing the high AC Armiger to share his AC bonus with comrades and shield him and them from AOE effects.
For the Player
If you want to be a great teammate on the battlefield, this class will give you the chance to be beneficial to all party members. I suggest going a medium armor route so that speed does not become an issue when trying to protect swifter party members.
For the Dungeon Master
Watch out for players who use this class and attempt to produce too high an AC. Also, the Armiger has an ability that some believe to be a bit broken, in that it can half any reflex save and in some cases, make them only a quarter as potent as they are suppose to be.
The Iron Word
The Genius Guide to the Armiger gives players a different kind of fighter, more adapt at protecting party members than dealing damage. It is as close as I hope D&D ever comes to an actual tank class.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Third Party Vendor’s takes on 4th edition adventures continues to outdo the corporate counter parts. Endless Winter is another strong showing, delivering a title that is far from frigid in the creative department.
Endless Winter establishes itself by beginning with a highly creative skill challenge and slowly ramps up the action dial as the adventure proceeds. An unnatural cold has taken over the land and the party must investigate the source and find the militia men who went to investigate.
Throughout the 43 pages, the writers have one of the most balanced efforts I have seen in 4th edition adventure of producing role playing opportunities, skill challenges and combat. Fans of thinking tactical encounters will be impressed with several sets of creatures that have the option of not being battled.
The layout of Winter is clean, crisp and highlights the well lined artwork. Most combats have an urgent sense of tactical design and require a bit of thinking and preplanning. This is easily an adventure that an unprepared party can TPK.
For the Dungeon Master
The writers utilize the environment very well. Thick mounds of snow, ice and wind conditions will all hamper your party in creative ways.
The Iron Word
Endless Winter is a fine adventure, really showing off what an adventure can do without tossing out enemy after enemy.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
If the plot of The Haunting of Soldragon Academy sounds familiar. It is because you are summoning up memories of many a morning in front of the television watching Scooby Doo Marathons. Though the plot follows a familiar formula, the adventure has a lively enough cask to almost reach a Supernatural episode.
Soldragon is a 26 page adventure that involves the PCs making a trip to a haunted academy. A ghost may be causing mayhem to the students and it is up to the PCs to solve the mystery before all the students leave. Mysteries are fairly hard to craft in Pathfinder, and the writer does a somewhat decent job in setting some initial stages, particularly finding out who the ghost is. Helpful sidebars and additional information in the Appendix go a long way to making the adventure easy to run. Despite using a haunting, the writer oddly did not attempt to use Pathfinder’s Haunts.
Soldragon feels like it needs a tad more punch, which is nothing that an experienced dungeon master can’t fix with a couple of well placed haunts. Where Souldragon shines is it’s character development. The kids are written well and contain the kind of dialogue to make your party members question child murder laws in a dungeons and dragons setting.
For the Dungeon Master
Despite some action short comings, the structure of Soldragon is crafted well. The encounters are thought out and well statted for the party level.
The Iron Word
The Haunting of Soldragon Academy is a good adventure for a party looking for a slight break after an intense story arc. The mystery would have worked better if played out more, but the role playing for the characters makes up for its brevity.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
It takes a special kind of mind to write The Breaking of Forstar Nagar.
I had the pleasure of meeting Ben McFarland at Gencon a few years ago. At the time, he had written was very adapt at crafting 3rd edition rules that enhanced gameplay, and I asked him if he was looking forward to Pathfinder. He was excited about the system, but was more interested in a critically acclaimed but not as popular system called Ars Magica. Working with a system like Ars Magica, a game designed where each player runs a trio of players, pushes a designer to create new methods of adventure design.
That push has paid off for McFarland with The Breaking of Forstar Nagar, an action congested 8th level pathfinder adventure that plays out like a perfectly directed action movie.
Forstar Nagar begins with the PCs having to break into a city of immense Ice and through a siege by a deadly group of cannibals called the Hungering Legion. They must break their way through several well designed, tactical combats into the heart of the city, rescue the survivors and decipher an escape plan.
What McFarland does that is impressive, is press home how deadly the bad guys are. Sure, their stat blocks are well written and complete with tactics. However, it is the intense description and reasoning included that allow the dungeon master the knowledge of how to play these characters correctly. McFarland also includes layers of backstory to every element of the adventure. By using a layered effect, Dungeon Masters have the option of blending in their own campaign elements or adding the writer’s preset layer.
To compliment the 48 pages of intense adventuring, detailed maps by one of the best in the business, Jonathan Roberts, highlights every encounter. Terrain elements and strategy is emphasized with every pen stroke. The artwork and layout are impressive, except for the decision to layer a blue background under black writing.
For the Dungeon Master
The adventure is very site based, meaning that PCs may venture into areas not in the order presented in the book. There are instructions and sidebars listed to handle most situations.
The Iron Word
The Breaking of Forstar is a very different kind of adventure that will be an action filled rump for any party. This adventure has something for everyone. As an added bonus, the adventure includes maptools files to run the game in the best online gaming tool on the market.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Iron Nugget
I love that Rite Publishing is not just rehashing Oriental Rules supplements, but actually designing an engrossing world set behind Japanese mythology. Way of the Yakuza is a sourcebook to allow you to either construct or run Yakuza in your Kaiden campaign or transfer the gang into your current campaign. The Old Japanese feel of the layout goes a long way to helping the reader understand how different the ways of the Yakuza are.
The 36 page PDF includes traits and feats to bring the Yakuza to life. However, the most creative features are the enchanting of tattoos and the base class archetypes that give DMs and Players the chance to Yakuza up their characters and NPCs without a major overhaul.
The Iron Word
The authors of the Kaiden campaign world are producing a fantastic mythology that blends Asian culture with the D&D realm. The Yakuza come off as violent individuals with a stern code of honor.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Publisher Reply: |
|
Nathan thanks for taking the time to do a review of our product, Steve Russell Rite Publishing |
|
|
|
|
|
|
A few months ago, I ran the first part of Blackbyrne’s Dark Veil campaign. The editing and descriptions were very well done and the ideas behind the adventures were cool and creative. Sands of Despair, the follow up campaign, is an expanded effort. It succeeds and fails exactly where the previous editions of the series do.
Sands of Despair is an Indiana Jones style campaign which embarks the PCs on a journey to recover the Artifacts of Dalacore in the Sands of Despair. The first part of the adventure has a linear structure and the second half of the 95-page adventure opens up a semi sandbox game where the players go back and forth through time. The last part brings the PCs back to the present time to recover one of the artifacts.
This is one of those adventures that has a ton of great concepts, but will need to be heavily adapted for any campaign. There aren’t too many series that makes me feel that I, the DM, is being railroaded. A problem with most of the series, this is very evident in time travel scenes where the PCs are locked events that are set places in time. The idea of going back in time to be apart of the battles is great, but the writer missed a great opportunity to incorporate the actual PCs impact on the history.
For the Dungeon Master
You got to love any adventure that combines worthy ideas with detailed maps.
The Iron Word
Sands of Despair churns some strong imagery in its descriptions and has a ton of great ideas. The adventure does need to be injected with a few puzzles and a tactical combat or two.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Publisher Reply: |
|
Hey Nathan,
Thanks for the review! I try and read every review and take something away from the comments to enhance the next adventure. One point (VERY small) that I'd like to make is; it's the Artifacts of Daggeroth the players are trying to find over the course of the Campaign Arc. On the point of the impact the players make on history, I must admit that I am a giant Star Trek fan and the Temporal Prime Directive has been drilled into my head, lol. All kidding aside, my intention was to actually not let the players make an impact on the past, however gain a firm grasp on the importance in their future, I will work to make that more clear in my future writing.
Thanks again!!
Jeff Gupton |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Iron Nugget
Not that bad for just over a book, but expect to do a bit of work with this one. How BAD is it is Library of Ancient Scroll's freshmen product. It is 7 pages of spell mishaps for those critical failures where the arcane is involved.
With so many flub charts running rampant on the internet, How Bad is it, succeeds at at settling on a niche, spell failure, and providing the beginnings of a chart for mishaps. Balancing is needed for many of the options. Also a bit of player testing would have eliminated some of the choices. For instance, I do like the idea of hiccuping for one round, but can't see how you can compare that penalty to blindness.
The Iron Word
The key to making this book work for you is to scrap the author's category system, rearrange the choices, eliminate the crazy ones and create a 1d6 chart of your own.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Publisher Reply: |
|
Thank You for Your review. It is very important for us, to recive feedback. We want to release better and better products. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mysteries are very hard to write in the D&D World. The system is not built for them. Adventure writers are too often trained to write towards the big battle. Publishers gear toward making more linear adventures to keep the page counts down. When they are attempted, rarely do they come off as a true mystery. I have run a few in my gaming background, and many times, my players tone out of the forced clues at locations or become bored by the lack of action. The Dying Skyseer, by Enworld Publishing, crushes the stereotype of the dull point to point D&D adventure and infuses a meaty mystery with enough role-playing, intrigue and action to satisfy an entire party.
What makes the 95-page Dying Skyseer so good is its sandbox approach to the mystery. Someone is dead, and the group must figure out who did it and why. There are a half dozen leads and avenues the party can investigate. Some will lead to the overall mystery, others are isolated sidequests that loosely link to the mystery. The writers never let the reader get lost. Some leads entangle sidequests, and the writer always includes several different scenarios that are broad enough to provide help for any situation that arises.
The layout is spectacular. Artwork that perfectly crosses fantasy with the industrial age. Vivid structuring and a sidebar answer every DM question. If you need to know what player traits do what, there’s a sidebar for that. If you need to know which NPCs do you have to keep alive, there’s a sidebar for that. Because this is EnWorld Publishing, if there’s something that is not answered the book, you can drop a message on the forum and the actual writer, Ryan Nock, will answer it, no matter what type of dumbfounded craziness occurs. There is no publisher that gives this level of customer service.
For the Dungeon Master
The effort put into the handouts is remarkable. Players will enjoy the city map and the extremely comprehensive bail certificate. It is the little touches like that that fulfill player immersion.
The Iron Word
I am approaching my last night of the adventure with my group, after 5 entertaining sessions and my party has not been this excited to participate in a climax in a long time. The adventure is spaciously designed to allow a group to be themselves, and tight enough where the party never feels lost and the dungeon master never needs to railroad. I fear reading the next installment of the Zeitgeist Campaign, as I am hard pressed to believe that anything will be able to top the level of detail and writing in this one.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mysteries are very hard to write in the D&D World. The system is not built for them. Adventure writers are too often trained to write towards the big battle. Publishers gear toward making more linear adventures to keep the page counts down. When they are attempted, rarely do they come off as a true mystery. I have run a few in my gaming background, and many times, my players tone out of the forced clues at locations or become bored by the lack of action. The Dying Skyseer, by Enworld Publishing, crushes the stereotype of the dull point to point D&D adventure and infuses a meaty mystery with enough role-playing, intrigue and action to satisfy an entire party.
What makes the 95-page Dying Skyseer so good is its sandbox approach to the mystery. Someone is dead, and the group must figure out who did it and why. There are a half dozen leads and avenues the party can investigate. Some will lead to the overall mystery, others are isolated sidequests that loosely link to the mystery. The writers never let the reader get lost. Some leads entangle sidequests, and the writer always includes several different scenarios that are broad enough to provide help for any situation that arises.
The layout is spectacular. Artwork that perfectly crosses fantasy with the industrial age. Vivid structuring and a sidebar answer every DM question. If you need to know what player traits do what, there’s a sidebar for that. If you need to know which NPCs do you have to keep alive, there’s a sidebar for that. Because this is EnWorld Publishing, if there’s something that is not answered the book, you can drop a message on the forum and the actual writer, Ryan Nock, will answer it, no matter what type of dumbfounded craziness occurs. There is no publisher that gives this level of customer service.
For the Dungeon Master
The effort put into the handouts is remarkable. Players will enjoy the city map and the extremely comprehensive bail certificate. It is the little touches like that that fulfill player immersion.
The Iron Word
I am approaching my last night of the adventure with my group, after 5 entertaining sessions and my party has not been this excited to participate in a climax in a long time. The adventure is spaciously designed to allow a group to be themselves, and tight enough where the party never feels lost and the dungeon master never needs to railroad. I fear reading the next installment of the Zeitgeist Campaign, as I am hard pressed to believe that anything will be able to top the level of detail and writing in this one.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Iron Nugget
I will give a full review of this book next month, after I finish reading and digesting it. Still, I can't imagine that the remaining 200 pages are not as thought provoking and engrossing as the first 200. Shannon Applecline is an amazing reviewer. Her comprehensive documentary on paper of the history of RPGs should be required reading for everyone. Instlead of a linear history, Applecline breaks down specific publishers that shaped D&D in a very unbiased way. She manages to shape emotion around fact without stepping into the middle of still ongoing disputes. From the Hasbro purchase of WOTC to the shunning of Dave Areneson at TSR, it is all covered in detail and clarity.
Iron Word
The best advice I have received on role-playing, whether as a player or a dm, has been from accomplished game designers talking to me outside of a game environment. Designers & Dragons is the voice of 4 decades of a powerful role playing soul telling you its story.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
If you want to achieve an eerie feeling in players, have children involved. There is something creepy about dead children that not too many other types of scare tactics can achieve. Some of the scariest movies of all time involve children terrorizing the adults in their life. Good Little Children Never Grow Up succeeds at providing a spooky Pathfinder adventure by taking advantage of the dead children premise.
Good Little Children, by Sneak Attack Press, is a 25 page mini-adventure with enough substance to take a party well into the night. There are no more than 3 encounters, but a good dungeon master can milk the role playing out of this adventure for an entire evening.
More than just a simple haunted house story, Good Little Children manages to rise above other adventures that fail to creep out players by separating the party mentally. Using a neat little handout system, players will perceive various portions of the house differently. It is much easier to take down a party when they are not on the same page.
For the Dungeon Master
The adventure follows a simple track, but has very colorful characters that can produce some strong role playing moments. This adventure can easily be wrapped around a Halloween game night one shot or inserted into a campaign.
The Iron Word
Forget Halloween candy, this nugget is a perfect little morsel for a Halloween Role Playing Game session. The simple nature is great for a group that does not meet regularly or for a DM who wants to have a minor diversion from their normal campaign.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Like watching a baby walk or a child ride a bike for the first time, thus is the feeling one receives when they watch a party behave like a team, using tactics, for the first time. Sure the first few sessions are placated with a me, myself and I attitude, but as they party together, there comes that moment where they do something tactical that puts a tear in a Dungeon Master’s eye.
The Secrets of Tactical Archetypes, by Rite Publishing, hopes to inspire more of these moments by providing 12 pages of tactical archetypes that emphasize on teamwork feats and abilities. There are six archetypes, one that can be tacked on to each of the six classes in Paizo’s Advanced Player’s Guide. An archetype if a pack of skills and abilities that can be swapped out for another. They are the “new” prestige class.
There is no slouch among the six archetypes. Each gives a completely different idea of the class and takes none of the usefulness away.
The layout and coloring of the work is bright and vibrant. As with most Rite products, the 12 pages feels like a lot more.
For the Player
Do your DM a favor if you want to play a bard and instead, play an Inspiring Commander. It is the most tactical of the archetypes. Rapid Tactician, the ability to distribute any known teamwork feat can insure that at least one person in the party is tactical without everyone needing to grab teamwork feats.
For the Dungeon Master
I am anxious to use the Pack Master Archetype as an NPC. The archetype allows a character to utilize more than one animal companion.
The Iron Word
The Secrets of Tactical Archetypes is a strong archetype book, possibly the strongest released so far. The six archetypes stand out and will provide a strategic variety of gameplay for a character looking to play something other than damage dealer or healer. Though the material is more than worth it, I left wishing that more core classes would have included a makeover.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Iron Nugget
Fast Fantasy is a series of PDFs that includes a detailed background of an NPC, as well as 4 statblocks of the character at low, mid and high level. The series does not include images, one of its biggest flaws, but does include, long well written prose to give a character enough of a background to infiltrate a campaign.
Fast Fantasy 4 gives us a wizard, Erinor Calmisius. Wild Hunt Games does a good job of creating a purposeful wizard. There is nothing special in the backstory to lean him closer to a villain or a hero, so DMs are welcome to add what they wish for the purpose they need.
The Iron Word
Fast FAntasy products are great little supplements to have nearby for those times when PCs meet or kill an NPC you had not planned for.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 0 items |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Log In 
![[PFRPG] The Genius Guide to the Armiger](images/97/82057-thumb100.jpg)
![[PFRPG] The Haunting of Soldragon Academy](images/2779/87966-thumb100.jpg)
.jpg)
